New Zealand · Oceania · Dessert
New Zealand lolly cake is not baked and barely resembles a conventional cake: crushed malt biscuits, condensed milk and butter form a fudgy log studded with colourful marshmallow sweets and rolled in coconut. Two hours of chilling turn it into neat café-style slices.

The story behind New Zealand lolly cake
This playful Kiwi slice is a familiar sight in cafés, school fundraisers and home baking tins. Older recipes often name a specific local marshmallow sweet; the category and branding have changed over time, but the technique remains recognisable. The sweet pieces should be soft and chewy rather than hard-boiled candy. This version is research-based and is not claimed as Dion’s personal test.
What defines this version
A malted biscuit crumb provides flavour and enough structure to slice. Warm butter and condensed milk bind the crumbs without baking. The log is kept compact, coated in desiccated coconut and chilled until firm; the colourful sweet pieces remain visible in every slice.
Spice level
○○○○○ 0/5 – No heat
There is no chilli or pungent spice. A small amount of vanilla is optional; the malt, coconut and fruit-marshmallow flavours should remain clear.
Ingredients and smart substitutions
Use malt biscuits such as Malt-O-Milk, Malted Milk or a comparable crisp malted tea biscuit. Plain digestive biscuits work structurally but give a less distinct malt flavour. Choose firm fruit-flavoured marshmallow sweets that can be cut cleanly; ordinary mini marshmallows are softer and make a paler, less traditional-looking slice. Use fine desiccated coconut rather than moist shredded coconut.
Helpful kitchen tools
A zip bag and rolling pin or food processor make even crumbs. You also need a small saucepan, large bowl, baking paper and a refrigerator-safe tray. A scale is especially helpful for this no-bake mixture because too much condensed milk makes it soft.
Before you start
Crush most biscuits finely but leave a few pea-size crumbs for texture. Let the warm butter mixture cool for a minute before adding the sweets so they do not melt. Compress the log firmly to prevent gaps, then chill it for the full two hours.
New Zealand Lolly Cake
Course: DessertCuisine: New ZealandDifficulty: Easy16
servings20
minutes2
hours20
minutesA classic Kiwi no-bake log of malt biscuit crumbs, condensed milk, butter and colourful fruit-marshmallow sweets, coated in coconut.
Ingredients
250 g malt biscuits
180 g firm fruit-flavoured marshmallow sweets, cut into 2 cm pieces
120 g unsalted butter
200 g sweetened condensed milk
1 tsp vanilla extract, optional
100 g fine desiccated coconut, divided
Method
- Line a tray with baking paper. Crush the malt biscuits to mostly fine crumbs, leaving a small handful of pea-size pieces for texture.
- Put the butter and condensed milk in a small saucepan. Warm over low heat, stirring, just until the butter has melted and the mixture is smooth; do not boil. Remove from the heat and stir in the vanilla, if using.
- Combine the biscuit crumbs and cut marshmallow sweets in a large bowl. Pour over the warm butter mixture and fold until every crumb is evenly moistened. Let it stand for 3 minutes if very soft.
- Spread 70 g coconut in an even rectangle on a fresh sheet of baking paper. Spoon the mixture along the centre, then use the paper to compress and roll it into a firm log about 6 cm in diameter.
- Roll the log through the coconut until fully coated, pressing on any bare patches. Wrap tightly in the paper and refrigerate for at least 2 hours, until firm.
- Unwrap and cut with a sharp knife into 16 slices about 1.5 cm thick. Wipe the blade between cuts for the cleanest colourful cross-sections.
Recipe notes
- The 140-minute total includes 2 hours of chilling. This is a no-bake recipe; the listed cooking time is therefore zero. Keep the log cold until it is firm enough to slice.
What to drink with lolly cake
Alcoholic: A lightly sparkling Moscato d’Asti echoes the fruit notes while its acidity keeps the condensed-milk sweetness in check.
Non-alcoholic: A New Zealand-style flat white or unsweetened black tea balances the rich, sweet slice.
Serving, storing and reheating
Keep the wrapped log or slices in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. Separate layers with baking paper. Freeze the unsliced log for up to 1 month, thaw overnight in the refrigerator and slice while still cool. Reheating is not recommended.
Allergen information
Contains: milk and gluten/wheat in standard biscuits and condensed milk. Biscuits, sweets and coconut may also carry soy, egg or tree-nut cross-contact warnings. Always check every ingredient label and consider cross-contamination in your own kitchen. Read our recipe and allergy disclaimer.
Frequently asked questions
What sweets can replace New Zealand lolly pieces?
Use firm fruit-flavoured marshmallow sweets that stay chewy when chilled. Avoid hard candy, jelly sweets that weep, and very soft mini marshmallows.
Why is my lolly cake too soft?
The mixture may be warm, under-chilled or measured with too much condensed milk. Compress it tightly and chill longer; do not add unmeasured liquid.
Can I make it gluten-free?
Yes, with a crisp gluten-free malt-style or plain tea biscuit. Check the sweets and vanilla too, and expect a slightly different flavour.
Culinary references
The characteristic no-bake biscuit, condensed-milk, lolly and coconut method was cross-checked with Woolworths New Zealand’s lolly cake. Ingredient options and the common café-style format were also checked against Foodlovers New Zealand.


